After graduating from college, I applied to 22 teaching jobs before finally landing one—at a juvenile detention facility. It was already October, my husband had just started grad school full-time, and we had no income to pay bills or buy groceries. I was desperate.
The rejections were tough. I took each one personally, even though I knew not all of them had to do with my qualifications. Still, rejection stings.
Fast forward twenty-five years, and I find myself in a similar place—putting my work out there and hoping someone says yes. These days, it’s not job applications but query letters. Every week, I send out ten or more, searching for that one literary agent willing to champion this first-time author and her manuscript.
Let me tell you—querying isn’t for the faint of heart. Thankfully, my time spent at Queens earning my MFA helped me develop thick skin in terms of receiving feedback related to my writing. Well-meaning, highly-qualified professors would give honest and necessary feedback in order to help me develop my writing and grow as a writer.
After graduation, I was accepted into the Book Development Program and paired with editor Alexa Pastor from Simon & Schuster. In our first Zoom session, she said, “I absolutely love your character Lily.” My heart soared. As my head began to swell and I envisioned book signings and public speaking events around the globe. Then came the follow-up: “I hate her story.”
Oof.
But instead of giving up, I rewrote the entire novel over the next six months. With Alexa’s guidance, Lily’s story transformed—and so did I.
Which brings me to today. Desperately seeking a literary agent and one of countless fish in the literary pond. And, because I’m casting my net wide, I’m also receiving rejections, almost daily. Some are generic and kind: “Thank you for submitting your manuscript. Unfortunately, at this time we are unable to offer you literary representation. It is not a reflection of your work and we hope you the best in your continued search.” Others have been a little more critical: “Our interest was piqued in your query letter; however, your early pages underwhelmed us.”
But I’m not alone.
A quick Google search reveals I’m in good company:
- Lisa Genova’s Still Alice: 100+ rejections
- Kathryn Stockett’s The Help: 60 rejections
- Stephen King’s Carrie: 30 rejections
- Madeleine L’Engle’s A Wrinkle in Time: 26 rejections
- John Grisham, A Time to Kill: 28 rejections
- Dr. Seuss, And to Think That I Saw It on Mulberry Street: 27 rejections
- Joseph Heller, Catch-22: 22 rejections
- William Golding, Lord of the Flies: 21 rejections
- Anne Frank, The Diary of Anne Frank: 15 rejections
- Chicken Soup for the Soul: 144 rejections
So, how do I handle all the “no’s”? I try to see each one as a step closer to the “yes.” I’m trying to rise above it and not take it personally. I remind myself that I’m filtering out the agents who aren’t a good fit, making space for the one who is.
A friend asked how my querying was going, and so I was honest about the emotional rollercoaster of receiving a rejection and needing to carry on and keep the faith. She directed me to this quote by Stephen King:
“By the time I was fourteen the nail in my wall would no longer support the weight of the rejection slips impaled upon it. I replaced the nail with a spike and went on writing.”
— Stephen King, On Writing
That gave me an idea. I grabbed a mason jar, stuffed it with a few dollar bills, and christened it my “Not Yet” jar. For every rejection, I add a dollar. One day, that jar will buy me something fun. If I get accepted tomorrow, maybe it’s a coffee and scone. If it takes 100 rejections, maybe it’s a first-class ticket to somewhere beautiful.
Right now, the jar sits on our kitchen counter. Sometimes I catch my daughter emptying it out to count the money. And honestly? I love that. I love that my kids see me staying hopeful, embracing rejection, and keeping the faith that “not yet” is just one step away from “yes.”





